Menu of Mr. Phil's Pizza in Brooklyn, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Mr. Phil's Pizza, nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 7212 New Utrecht Ave, offers a genuine slice of classic New York pizza culture with an authentic neighborhood vibe. This pizzeria carries the essence of traditional Brooklyn joints—unpretentious, reliable, and driven by a deep respect for time-tested flavors.

One of the standout highlights on the menu is undoubtedly their Upside-Down Slice and Upside Down Pizza. These unique takes present the familiar in an exciting format, layering cheese beneath the sauce for a rich, tangy bite that balances perfectly with the crisp, yet tender crust. The Chicken Pizza, a flavorful alternative to the traditional slices, showcases succulent pieces of chicken harmonizing with their signature sauce and cheese. For classicists, the Regular Pizza Slice stays true to the roots with a comforting blend of melted mozzarella and savory tomato sauce.

Beyond pizza, Mr. Phil’s menu impresses with its specialty calzones and rolls, such as the Pepperoni Pinwheel and the Pepperoni and Ham Roll. These handheld delights combine the richness of Italian sausage, mozzarella, and red sauce into crisp, golden parcels bursting with flavor. The Chicken Roll and Vegetable Roll provide lighter yet equally satisfying options, packed with fresh ingredients like romaine, croutons, and assorted cheeses.

The Italian specialties offered demonstrate a deeper culinary skill and commitment to classic Italian-American dishes. Veal Francese and Veal Marsala are meticulously prepared with robust white wine and mushroom sauces, showcasing tender cuts of meat that are beautifully complemented by fresh arugula and olive oil. The Chicken Marsala and Chicken Francese bring a delicate balance of lemon, white wine, and butter, served with pasta—a testament to Phil’s dedication to authentic, hearty flavors.

Customers repeatedly praise the consistency of Mr. Phil’s offerings. Regulars appreciate the “reliable pie every time,” highlighting the well-balanced dough, sauce, and cheese that define a good New York-style slice. The slightly undercooked shorter bake preferred by many lends a perfect chew and moist texture that keeps patrons coming back. The delivery service is noted for being both fast and friendly, adding to the overall positive experience.

Beyond the pizza, the fried calzone filled with ham and cheese is frequently recommended, with a perfect golden crust encasing melty, savory goodness. Additionally, side dishes like the Italian rice balls (Arancini) are applauded for their moist texture and exquisite balance of filling and rice, while the Sicilian squares offer a satisfying, hearty alternative for those seeking variety.

Mr. Phil’s Pizza is more than just a place to grab a slice; it’s a neighborhood fixture with a classic, unrenovated Brooklyn atmosphere that evokes nostalgia and comfort. While its signature garlic knots have lost their extra garlic topping recently, the atmosphere and attitude add to the authentic experience, embodying the straightforward charm of classic NYC pizzerias.

In sum, Mr. Phil’s Pizza presents a menu that resonates with tradition and consistency. Whether you’re after a unique upside-down slice, a hearty Italian specialty, or a quick, satisfying calzone, you’ll find a menu that honors the essence of Brooklyn pizza culture with dependable quality and robust flavors.